Pixel

The Disappearing 75%: What Films Teach Novelists About Context

November 17, 2026: MCS & Story Development, Writing Process & Planning, Chapters & Openings, Mindset & Motivation
😃   Subscribe for Post Emails:
Nov 17: MCS & Story Development, Writing Process & Planning, Chapters & Openings, Mindset & Motivation
The Disappearing 75%: What Films Teach Novelists About Context
Nov 3: Writing Process & Planning, Feedback & Retelling, Contests & Anthologies
Subjectivity Is No Excuse: Actionable Feedback with the Publishability Index™
Oct 20: Writing Process & Planning, Mindset & Motivation, Marketing & Promotion, Publishing & Career
Who Chases Whom? Write a Great Manuscript So Literary Agents Pursue You
Oct 6: MCS & Story Development, Writing Process & Planning, Chapters & Openings
Pantsers Flail, Plotters Prevail: One Column with Three Keys to Unlock Your Plot
Sep 22: MCS & Story Development, Writing Process & Planning
Sketch Your Next Novel Our Way; Get Started in One Day
Sep 8: MCS & Story Development, Writing Process & Planning, Feedback & Retelling
Good Spiraling: Conscientiously Add Ideation and Feedback to Write Better Novels
Aug 25: MCS & Story Development, Writing Process & Planning
Once Upon a Time? What Fairy Tales Teach Novelists About Memory and Writing
Aug 11: Writing Process & Planning, Chapters & Openings
Part 3: Mastering the 100,000-Word Novel Budget: Multivalue Paragraphs
Jul 28: Writing Process & Planning, Chapters & Openings
Part 2: Mastering the 100,000-Word Novel Budget: Satisfying Chapters
Jul 14: MCS & Story Development, Writing Process & Planning, Chapters & Openings
Part 1: How to Master the 100,000-Word Novel Budget and Make Every Word Count
Jun 30: Feedback & Retelling, Writer Personas, Mindset & Motivation
Isolation's Impact: Evidence that Authors Misjudge Their Work
Jun 16: MCS & Story Development, Chapters & Openings, Feedback & Retelling
Unlocking Story Sense: The Differentiator Between Good and Great Authors
Jun 2: Contests & Anthologies, Publishing & Career
Creation vs. Generation: Drawing a Non-technical Red Line Between Human Authorship and AI
May 19: Marketing & Promotion, Publishing & Career
Author Bio: From Bore to Brand with an Irresistible Tidbit in 6 Steps
May 5: Marketing & Promotion, Publishing & Career
Five Steps to a better Novel Cover: The A.T.E. Roadmap
Apr 21: Marketing & Promotion, Publishing & Career
Writers as Solepreneurs: Why Finishing your Novel Opens the Best Door to a Rewarding Business
Apr 14: Marketing & Promotion, Publishing & Career
How Authors Can Succeed During Economic Downturns
Apr 8: MCS & Story Development, Writing Process & Planning, Publishing & Career
Have Sales Chase You: Select Writing Projects with Passion and Potential
Mar 25: Writing Process & Planning, Chapters & Openings, Feedback & Retelling
The Art of Orientation: Anchoring Your Reader at Every Chapter Break
Mar 11: Feedback & Retelling, Writer Personas, Mindset & Motivation
How to Cultivate "Healthy Arrogance": Part 2: The Confidence You Need to Break Through as a Novelist
Feb 25: Feedback & Retelling, Writer Personas, Mindset & Motivation
How to Cultivate "Healthy Arrogance": Part 1: What Not to Do
Feb 11: MCS & Story Development, Writing Process & Planning, Feedback & Retelling
Stop Writing in a Straight Line: The Power of Nonlinear Novel Development
Jan 29: Writing Process & Planning, Feedback & Retelling
The Waiter Problem: Why Authors Need True Product Testing
Jan 15: MCS & Story Development, Writing Process & Planning, Publishing & Career
Separability Secrets: Why Subpar Prose Sells & 3 Ways that Helps Your Novels
Dec 10: MCS & Story Development, Characters
Create Authentic, Investable Characters: A Free Comprehensive Online Developer
Dec 3: MCS & Story Development, Writing Process & Planning
How to Crystallize Your Novel’s Narrative: The 4 Stages of the Minimum Complete Story
Nov 12: MCS & Story Development, Writing Process & Planning, Marketing & Promotion
The 9-Sentence Novel: How to Build a Minimum Complete Story (MCS)
Nov 5: MCS & Story Development, Writing Process & Planning, Feedback & Retelling
Our Minimum Complete Story (MCS): Better Novels in 90 Seconds
Oct 29: MCS & Story Development, Characters
Example Character: Meet Pat the Firefighter
Oct 22: MCS & Story Development, Characters
Character Recipe Step 2: Blend Your Equation Ingredients to Relatable Beings
Oct 16: MCS & Story Development, Characters
Character Equation Three: Steal Distinctiveness from Referents You Know
Oct 9: Feedback & Retelling, Marketing & Promotion, Publishing & Career
Turn Readers into Superfans: Build Two-Way Connections
Oct 1: MCS & Story Development, Characters
Character Equation Two: Take Advantage of Readers' Cultural Knowledge
Sep 23: MCS & Story Development, Characters
Character Equation One: Steal Parts of Yourself For A Publishable Character
Sep 17: Feedback & Retelling, Publishing & Career
The Publishability Index™: A Checklist for Your Story
Sep 11: Chapters & Openings, Feedback & Retelling, Contests & Anthologies
Four Musts for Compelling First Chapters
Sep 4: Writer Personas, Mindset & Motivation
What's Your Writer Persona? Message Morgan
Aug 28: Writer Personas, Mindset & Motivation, Publishing & Career
What's Your Writer Persona? Grandiose Gary
Aug 21: Writer Personas, Mindset & Motivation, Publishing & Career
What's Your Writer Persona? Publication Pat
Aug 7: Writer Personas, Mindset & Motivation
What's Your Writer Persona? Motivation Max
Jul 30: Writer Personas, Mindset & Motivation
What's Your Writer Persona? Learning Logan
Jul 9: MCS & Story Development, Writing Process & Planning
Bardsy's MCS: A Small Story That Makes a Big Difference
Jun 25: Chapters & Openings, Feedback & Retelling
How to Hook Your Readers (and Keep Them) via Commonality
Jun 11: Mindset & Motivation, Publishing & Career
Stories, Sweat, and Tears: 6 Tips for Writers Dealing with Rejection
Jun 4: Feedback & Retelling, Marketing & Promotion
Effectively Using Beta Readers in 2025
May 21: Writing Process & Planning, Mindset & Motivation
Have Something to Show for Your Summer
May 15: Writing Process & Planning, Feedback & Retelling
A Guide to Bardsy's Directed Writing Groups
Apr 24: Writing Process & Planning, Feedback & Retelling, Mindset & Motivation
What Can a Writing Coach Do for You?
Feb 23: Mindset & Motivation, Contests & Anthologies, Publishing & Career
Thanks, but No Thanks: When Your Writing Gets Rejected
Feb 16: Writing Process & Planning, Feedback & Retelling, Contests & Anthologies
Winning Revisions: Making Writing Feedback Work for You
Feb 5: Writing Process & Planning, Feedback & Retelling
Collecting Writing Feedback You Can Actually Use
Jan 22: Chapters & Openings, Feedback & Retelling, Contests & Anthologies
Is My First Chapter a Winner?
Jan 15: Marketing & Promotion, Publishing & Career
Social Media for Authors: A Marketing Mindset
Dec 30: Marketing & Promotion, Publishing & Career
But I Don't Want to be an Influencer . . . Social Media for Authors
Dec 18: Writer Personas, Mindset & Motivation, Publishing & Career
What's Your Writer Persona? Hobbyist Hayden + Career Cary
Dec 10: Feedback & Retelling, Writer Personas, Mindset & Motivation
What's Your Writer Persona? Social Sam
Jun 12: Writing Process & Planning, Writer Personas, Mindset & Motivation
Planning Your Success: We're Here to Help!
Jun 5: Feedback & Retelling, Contests & Anthologies, Publishing & Career
Fear Not ChatGPT: Only Humans Can Judge Writing Contests (And Stories)
Apr 23: Feedback & Retelling, Contests & Anthologies, Publishing & Career
Bardsy's 2024 Anthology Contest
Apr 10: MCS & Story Development, Writing Process & Planning, Feedback & Retelling
How to Prototype Your Novel and Ensure Coherence via Short Stories
Mar 19: MCS & Story Development, Writing Process & Planning
The Art of Memoir: Exploring the Intersection of Truth and Storytelling
Jan 17: Mindset & Motivation, Publishing & Career
Decisions, Decisions: Choosing a Writing Conference & Maximizing Your Time
Jan 3: Mindset & Motivation, Publishing & Career
Writing Conferences: A Writer’s Paradise or a Wasted Weekend?
Sep 6: Chapters & Openings, Feedback & Retelling, Contests & Anthologies
What Makes a First Chapter Anthology Contest Finalist??
Jul 19: Contests & Anthologies, Marketing & Promotion, Publishing & Career
Become a Published Author: What Goes Into Self-Publishing on Amazon
Jul 5: Contests & Anthologies, Publishing & Career
What Anthology Publication Can Do for You
Jun 28: Feedback & Retelling, Contests & Anthologies
How to Win Writing Contests by Passing These 3 Tests
May 10: Contests & Anthologies, Publishing & Career
Your Guide to Entering—and Winning—Writing Contests
May 3: Writing Process & Planning, Feedback & Retelling
How Great Writing Workshops Work
Mar 1: Feedback & Retelling, Contests & Anthologies
The Best Feedback You Will Ever Receive
Feb 15: Writer Personas, Mindset & Motivation
Writing Personas: Ready Riley!
Feb 6: Marketing & Promotion, Publishing & Career
7 Tips for Writing an Author Bio That Gets You Noticed
Jan 31: Marketing & Promotion, Publishing & Career
Yes, You Need an Author Website—Even If You’re Unpublished
Jun 22: Mindset & Motivation, Contests & Anthologies, Publishing & Career
Small Steps to Big Success with Bardsy Anthologies
Jun 15: Writing Process & Planning, Mindset & Motivation
You’ll Love Writing with Will.Power
Jun 8: Writing Process & Planning, Feedback & Retelling, Contests & Anthologies
Submit Early for Success
May 10: Writing Process & Planning, Mindset & Motivation
Determine the Next Step in Your Writing
May 4: Writing Process & Planning, Mindset & Motivation
Break Through Your Blocks with Will.Power
Mar 24: Contests & Anthologies, Publishing & Career
Avoid Instant Disqualification
Dec 14: Feedback & Retelling, Contests & Anthologies
Give and Ye Shall Receive
Nov 8: MCS & Story Development, Writing Process & Planning, Contests & Anthologies
Turn Your Short Story Into a Novel

Takeaway

Many movies and novels tell the same story in different ways. Examining these adaptations can help us write better. This post details one lesson on context and how it's delivered. Here's the key fact: Denis Villeneuve’s Dune films kept only about a quarter of Frank Herbert’s words. The premise is that these discarded words, what we're calling context, reached the screen through a budget of millions and a crew of hundreds. Now, that's just one difference; filmmakers also control what viewers see and how fast. In contrast, authors have only words, while readers control what they imagine and can stop at any time.
That makes supplying enough of the right context one of the novelist’s biggest jobs. The lesson: give readers enough to fully imagine and understand each scene, and choose every detail for relevance, empathy, or meaning. Too much becomes an info dump; too little leaves readers guessing or closing the book.
quotemark

Up to 75 percent of a novel is context, so getting it right is crucial.

Fill Reel and Slate
What information does a reader need? With our First Chapter Anthology Contest open through December 11, we’ve been reading plenty of first chapters, and this question keeps coming up. Some openings stop the story for pages of backstory, the dreaded info dump. Others race ahead and leave readers unsure about what's going on or why any of it matters. Both problems come down to context: too much or not enough.
Movies offer novelists a solid comparison that helps answer this question. They tell stories too, often the same ones, just in a different format. Both also get one shot to tell that story and please their audience. Beyond proving that story can be separated from form, adaptations show what authors must do in terms of context. This post uses Frank Herbert’s Dune, perhaps the greatest science fiction novel ever written, and its recent adaptations. Astonishingly, the first thing this examination reveals is that up to 75 percent of a novel's words may be context.
Let’s back up that estimate, as it seems suspiciously high.

One Story, Two Formats

Denis Villeneuve’s two film scripts, Dune: Part One (2021) and Dune: Part Two (2024), cover the whole novel, the first in the series, yet they have only about a quarter of its words: roughly 46,000 against about 188,000. That’s a fact. Then hearing those words, as an audiobook, takes about four times as long as watching the movies: about 21 hours against just over five. So, three-quarters of the novel essentially disappears in adaptation. Context is the leading culprit, the reason the extra words were not necessary. Of course, this content does reach the screen; indeed it must in order to tell a coherent story and satisfy the audience. However, it appears as locations, sets, sound, faces, effects, and the like. So, when we answer authors, we say readers need “enough” context, and thinking about films shows how much and what you need at any point in your writing.
First, though, what does context itself mean?

Context Determines (and Can Change) Meaning

Take a look at this famous optical illusion, W. E. Hill’s 1915 drawing “My Wife and My Mother-in-Law.” Look one way and you see a young woman turning away; look another and you see an old woman in profile. The image itself does not change. The difference in interpretation lies in what you perceive as foreground and background. Specifically, their relationship determines what we actually see.
Hill 1915 Optical Illusion
This phenomenon sets up how novelists should think about context. For us, context is the information surrounding the action, what readers need to imagine and understand the happenings. So, context frames a story’s events. A character slamming a door means one thing after a betrayal and something else entirely in a chase. Here are two implications to remember. First, change the context, and you change the meaning. Second, there is no meaning without context, so you either supply it to the reader or they will make up their own.
That foreground-background distinction allows us to pinpoint the difference between movies and novels. On page one of a novel and in the first seconds of a movie, audiences know nothing; the context sets the stage, the background: setting, mood, characters, and so on. A film handles much of this in its opening shots, with landscape, music, and actors’ physicality. This comparison shows us what authors have to build in words: enough of what the film delivers for readers to imagine each scene, but no more. That’s where many first chapters overload or underdeliver.

Where the 75 Percent Goes

The Dune movies literally let you see, hear, and maybe feel that 75 percent. The deserts of Arrakis are real places: the rock formations of Wadi Rum in Jordan, for instance. Caladan’s sea cliffs came from Norway. For the Harkonnen world, Giedi Prime, the cinematographer shot in infrared, which bleaches the planet into black and white, showing a world that’s alien and hostile. Sound and score carry the dread of a sandworm before it appears. None of this needs one word of dialogue.
The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences noticed: Dune: Part One won six Oscars, for cinematography, film editing, original score, production design, sound, and visual effects, every one a context job. On the other hand, the remaining 25 percent, the screenplay, was nominated but lost, and none of its actors were nominated.
Not only do filmmakers deliver context through image and sound, they have other advantages authors lack. These show up along at least three dimensions: product, control, and experience. All of these should further inform your thinking about the burden your words carry.

Movie Production Takes a Village

Start with the product. As noted earlier, we can separate a story from its format. The same story can be told aloud, written as a novel, or filmed. Adaptations prove the point: The Godfather, Jaws, and Gone Girl all began as novels and turned into films that let audiences embrace roughly the same story. Put simply, the new medium did not fundamentally alter the story’s five elements: characters, world, conflict, theme, and plot.
The format change shows up first in the budget. Villeneuve's two Dune films cost a reported $355 million to produce, and that's before marketing. Films also often take years of development, shooting, and postproduction. A novel, by contrast, requires no capital and little crew. Production time, naturally, varies wildly.
A film’s budget hires a large crew, often hundreds of people. Listing these roles, grouped into seven areas, outlines what context your words may need to cover, specifically: direction; camera and lighting; art; costume, hair, and makeup; sound and effects; cast and stunts; and postproduction. Film production is complex, so this list is not definitive. Here it is for your reference now and in the future:
  • Direction: director, production and location managers, script supervisor
  • Camera and lighting: cinematographer, gaffers, grips
  • Art: art director, set decorators, storyboards, props, construction and scenic crew
  • Costume, hair, and makeup: designers, wardrobe, makeup and hair artists
  • Sound and effects: production sound mixer, VFX crew, techs
  • Cast and stunts: actors, extras, stunt performers, stand-ins, choreographer
  • Postproduction: editor, colorist, sound designers, Foley artist, mixers, composer
Let’s go through acting as one example to show exactly how motion pictures replace words.

What Actors Bring, Authors Must Supply

Actors collaborate to bring a character to life, actively co-creating with the rest of the crew. Here's some of what they add when saying their lines:
  1. Physicality: a body, a face, a voice, and a way of moving, not to mention their costume, hair, and makeup. Further, the audience takes much of this in at a glance.
  2. Identity: casting provides context, too. When Villeneuve chose Jason Momoa to play Duncan Idaho, he likely foresaw that moviegoers would already kind of know him: a wild and happy yet loyal warrior. We call that a type, the kind of character Momoa usually plays. His lines, in consequence, are more effective; they sound more organic and reinforce an existing identity, again at a glance.
  3. Emotion: When the director zooms in, an actor’s face makes a feeling recognizable without words. A close-up reveals, for example, a tightening jaw or a tiny tear to prompt a sympathetic viewer reaction in a fraction of a second.
Authors don't have these tools. Their words have to compensate for everything an actor supplies. Naturally, we can't describe everything. That said, authors can count on their audience to complete an identity. Thus, compensating translates to giving enough detail for readers to accurately bring the character to imaginative life. Our free character developer can help you thread this needle.

Filmmakers Control the Audience; Authors Don’t

The second dimension is control, and here authors operate at a disadvantage. Consider:
  1. Speed: film runs at 24 frames per second. Within that realm, directors set the pace. Moreover, no one stops to rewind. Readers set their own speed. They skim, skip, or reread as they please.
  2. Attention: a close-up or lighting tells viewers where to look. On the page, nothing stops a reader’s eye from overlooking critical details.
  3. Distraction: moviegoers sit fairly still for two uninterrupted hours. Readers take breaks, sometimes for days, and must find their place again on return. This is why we're so fond of orienting readers at the start of each scene.
  4. Completion: most viewers watch movies to the end. Readers who lose interest simply stop, and the book gets a DNF (did not finish).
In short, filmmakers can inject context, like a hypodermic needle, giving a measured dose to the right place. Authors do their best and trust readers to get it.

Yet Novels May Be the Best Virtual Reality

The third dimension is the experience, which may be where novels truly win. Access to a character’s inner life, for example, differs sharply. Film struggles to show thought. Voiceovers feel clumsy, so filmmakers lean on the actor’s face, which can show emotion but not complex reasoning. Novels offer telepathy. In Dune, for example, readers follow Paul’s thoughts, even imagining what he imagines; on screen his inner life plays out largely on Timothée Chalamet’s face, clunky narration, or special effects.
Here’s the key difference: viewers observe, readers imagine. Viewers spectate, react, and feel sympathy for the people on screen. Readers co-create each scene from the author’s words, and because they have to imagine it themselves, they feel empathy. They share the character’s experience rather than watching it. Forget Meta Quest or Apple Vision Pro, a well-written novel may be the best virtual reality around. However, the simulation succeeds only if readers have enough raw material.

Context, Not Padding, Makes Up Most of a Great Novel

Overall, this 75 percent figure is remarkable. Dune is no bloated beginner’s manuscript; it’s a celebrated classic, yet roughly three of every four words can be seen as context. Context isn’t padding. In a great novel, it’s often most of the book; it’s what lets readers imaginatively experience the story, and what gives it meaning. The need for context also carries risk: when it doesn’t work, it becomes an info dump or leaves readers guessing.

What Context Must Do: Relevance, Empathy, Meaning

So what does context actually do? Since readers control the pace and can quit at any time, every sentence of context earns its place by doing at least one, if not more, of three jobs:
  1. Relevance: it progresses the story. This is the key test. A detail about a character’s past belongs if it shapes a decision now; if it doesn’t, it’s on its way to becoming an info dump.
  2. Empathy: it lets readers share the character’s experience: what they see, hear, want, and suffer.
  3. Meaning: it gives events their resonance, so readers understand why something matters.
Fall short, and readers start guessing. Guessing readers get confused or bored, and may stop reading altogether. The target is sufficient context: enough to imagine and understand but no more, delivered right when the story demands it.

Example: Putting Context to Work in Your First Chapter

How does this work in practice? Take your first chapter and mark every passage of context, such as description, backstory, explanation, and setting. For each one, ask which of the three jobs it does. If it does none, cut it or move it to the point where it becomes relevant. Then read the chapter as a stranger would. Wherever a reader could lose track of who, where, or why, add just enough to keep them oriented.
For example, Jackie, a Bardsy Elite member, has a vampire romantasy, where the inciting incident turns on a flower that can be used to overthrow the vampires' cruel reign. That’s essential context. Facts about the vampires' cruelty and power are also essential to raise the stakes. Readers who aren’t told how her vampires work will fill the gaps with their own defaults and probably miss the flower's import. Working through the pre-MCS allowed her to sort out which pieces readers need from the start, which can wait until they become relevant, and which to leave out.
Knowing your story makes these calls easier. If you haven’t settled your story’s elements yet, our free pre-MCS asks for one sentence per element as a first step toward saying your Minimum Complete Story (MCS), your story told aloud in about two minutes.
Remember: a film needs hundreds of people to deliver the context a novelist supplies alone, in words. Much of a great novel is context, and it works because that context does its job. Yours can too.
We look forward to your thoughts or questions at joinus@bardsy.com.
TO DO SCRATCHPAD PRIVATE JOURNAL TRACKING Update Assessment
CLICK A TAB TO USE WILL.POWER

TO DO LIST:
Add tasks to your sortable list, then revel in checking them off.

SCRATCHPAD:
Cache your gems as they fall in this always accessible place.

PRIVATE JOURNAL:
Reflect on your process — good, bad and ugly — in your dated diary.

TRACKING:
Measure your progress with key writing metrics, automatically,
ADD DO
Show Dones
Metric:
Words
Minutes
ADD
Click anywhere to close / cancel